ClubLocationLeagueTierFounded
New York Red Bulls U23New York City, NYDissolved 2021—2009New York SkylinersNew York City, NYDissolved 1968—1966New York Soccer ClubNew York City, NYDissolved 1930—1923New York UkrainiansNew York City, NYCSL - Division 1RL-21947New York YankeesNew York City, NYDissolved 1931—1930Polonia GreenpointNew York City, NYDissolved 19??—19??
Royston FCYorkshireDissolved UNK—UNKSt. John's Red StormNew York City, NYNCAA Division ICL-11979SwedishNew York City, NYDissolved 19??—19??York CityYorkNational League51908
York LionsYork—